Parental Rights in LGBTQ+ Families: Judicial Parenthood Order or Adoption?
Legal recognition of parenthood in LGBTQ+ families has developed considerably in recent years. Today there are two main routes for recognising the parenthood of the partner who is not the biological parent: a judicial parenthood order and adoption. Which one fits depends on the family's circumstances.
Judicial parenthood order
The judicial parenthood order was developed in case law. It recognises the non-biological parent as a parent from the date of birth, not only from the date of the order.
This route is especially suitable for female couples who had a child through sperm donation, where one partner carried the pregnancy. Family Courts have also granted such orders in cases of surrogacy abroad where one partner is the biological parent, but the case law on this point is not uniform.
Adoption
Adoption is governed by the Adoption of Children Law, 5741-1981. It is required, for example:
When neither partner has a genetic link to the child.
When adopting a partner's child from a previous relationship.
In cases of surrogacy abroad where a judicial parenthood order was not granted.
The process is longer and more complex, and involves social services and welfare reports.
The main differences
Parenthood recognised from: Judicial parenthood order: The date of birth; Adoption: The date of the adoption order
Length of process: Judicial parenthood order: Relatively short, especially if filed close to the birth; Adoption: Longer
Social services involvement: Judicial parenthood order: Limited; a welfare report is sometimes required; Adoption: Full, including reports
What must be shown: Judicial parenthood order: A stable relationship and a shared intention to parent; Adoption: Full parental suitability and the child's best interests
Recommendations
Seek legal advice as early as possible, ideally before the birth.
Prepare in advance the documents showing the relationship and the shared intention to parent.
File the right application at the right time.
Every case is different, and choosing the right route can save a great deal of time and distress.
For a consultation: Maya Kedem, Adv., Attorney and Mediator · +972-54-775-7505
This article provides general information, is current as of its publication date, and is not legal advice or a substitute for consulting a lawyer.





Comments