Contesting a Will: When and How?
A will is a document in which a person decides what will happen to their property after death. In Israel, the Succession Law, 5725-1965, governs how a will is made, how it is given effect and how it can be contested.
What is a probate order?
To carry out the will, an application for a probate order is filed with the Registrar of Inheritance Affairs. The application is published, and anyone who considers themselves affected may file an objection. If no objection is filed, the Registrar issues the order.
What is an objection to a will?
An objection is a claim that the will, in whole or in part, should not be given effect. It is filed with the Registrar of Inheritance Affairs, and once filed, the case is transferred to the Family Court, which hears it.
Main grounds for objection
Defect in form - the will was not made in one of the forms the law recognises: handwritten, before witnesses, before an authority, or oral. However, under section 25 of the Law, the court may uphold a will despite a defect in form if it has no doubt that the will reflects the testator's wishes.
Lack of capacity - the testator could not understand the nature of a will when making it, for example due to cognitive decline.
Undue influence, coercion, threats or fraud - a provision made in such circumstances is void.
Involvement of a beneficiary - a provision in favour of a person who drafted the will, witnessed it or took part in making it is generally void.
A later will - a new will that revokes the earlier one, in whole or in part.
Balancing the testator's wishes and the heirs' rights
The law seeks to respect the testator's wishes, and the courts give great weight to the terms of a will. The objector must therefore present real evidence of a defect.
For example, if the testator left everything to a caregiver, and there is evidence that the caregiver controlled the testator's life, isolated them from their family and was involved in making the will, the will may be set aside. If, on the other hand, the will is shown to have been made properly and to reflect the testator's wishes, the objection will be dismissed.
In summary
Contesting a will is a significant process that requires careful examination of the facts and the law. It is important to act in time and to consult a lawyer who practises inheritance law, to assess the prospects and build the objection correctly.
For a consultation: Maya Kedem, Adv., Attorney and Mediator · +972-54-775-7505
This article provides general information, is current as of its publication date, and is not legal advice or a substitute for consulting a lawyer.





Comments